Some customers say an AI-generated flyer is enough to make them pass on a business before they ever walk through the door.
That was a recurring response in a public Ann Arbor Area Community Facebook discussion started October 24 by freelance writer Sarah Good-Lang. She asked business owners and patrons for views on AI flyers, both for and against, for an article she was researching.
The replies offer Livingston County businesses a look at a nearby community’s debate over advertising. They reflect the people who chose to comment in that thread, not a representative survey or proof that a particular business has lost sales.
“I’ve decided against patronizing certain businesses”
Leah Vee put her objection in terms of where she spends money.
“I’ve decided against patronizing certain businesses because of their AI flyers, and I will continue to do so.”
Susan Lynn Whitmarsh also said she would take her business elsewhere, calling AI promotion “artificial and insulting.”
For those commenters, the flyer communicates something about the business itself. Billy Bitonti, who identified himself as a graphic designer, questioned whether a lack of effort in advertising might carry over into the service being promoted. He also acknowledged his personal stake in protecting creative jobs.
Those are customers’ perceptions. An advertisement alone does not establish how carefully someone prepares food, runs a shop or serves customers. But the comments show how quickly a marketing choice can shape that first impression.
Real products and a recognizable voice
Food imagery drew particular criticism. Aliyah Mack-Layher wrote:
“I tend to avoid going to places who use ai to advertise their food. Especially when the photo of said food is ai.”
Kim Hurt criticized crowded layouts and a lack of space around important information. “I don’t even bother looking at them, just keep scrolling,” Hurt wrote.
The complaints were about more than whether a graphic looked polished. Commenters wanted to recognize the actual product, understand the offer and see something that felt specific to the business.
A simple flyer can be enough
Hannah Jones, who identified herself in the discussion as the owner of Dungeons and Draughts, said a small marketing budget did not change her preference.
“My take is I’d rather make a very simple flyer myself than use AI.”
Jones said the new business could not afford to hire an artist for every flyer and raised objections about artists’ work being used to build AI systems. Other commenters raised environmental concerns. Those broader claims were opinions expressed in the thread; this article does not independently assess a particular AI system’s training material or environmental footprint.
Why some small operators still use them
Brittany Barlow offered a different explanation. Identifying herself as the owner of a nonprofit rescue and sanctuary, she described AI flyers as a practical response to limited time and technical skills.
“I use AI flyers because I can make them quickly and easily. I’m not electronically savvy and I don’t have much time to spare.”
Hollie Marie also pushed back against criticism of small operators: “I’m not shaming a local mom and pop shop who would never hire a graphic artist to begin with.”
That disagreement matters. Some people see an unwanted shortcut; others see a tool that helps them get an announcement finished. The thread does not establish that every customer notices AI imagery or reacts to it the same way.
For a business deciding what to post next, the criticism offers a useful starting point: show the real product, make the details easy to read and pay attention to how customers respond. Several people in this discussion said they would welcome a simple homemade flyer. What they objected to was advertising they felt they could not trust.
Source: Sarah Good-Lang’s public Facebook post and named comments in Ann Arbor Area Community, reviewed October 28, 2026. Quotations are from that discussion, not interviews conducted by Livingston Connect. Read the original post and replies.
Source: Sarah Good-Lang’s public Ann Arbor Area Community Facebook discussion
🔥 Never miss a game, event, or something fun happening near you!
🎉 From softball games and fishing tournaments to festivals, river tubing, and local events—there’s always something going on in Livingston County.
🎁 Plus get exclusive coupons, local deals, and even free birthday dinners from participating spots 🎂
📬 Join now and get everything sent straight to your inbox. No spam, just the good stuff 👀


Leave a Reply